Thursday, December 18, 2014

Group of Five Teams Need Objectivity

The chart below lists the number of top one finishes through top 20 finishes for non-power league teams under five different ranking methods from 1978 to 2013. The five methods in order are the Associated Press Poll, the Power Points System, the Power Points System with major teams spotted a one game lead, the Net Wins System which is a best record wins method, and the Net Wins System with major teams spotted a one game lead. The results below show that even objective methods that spot major teams a one game advantage are more favorable to non-power teams than a purely subjective method.


# AP PP P1 NW N1
1 1 1 0 4 1
2 1 2 0 13 1
3 3 5 1 16 2
4 3 11 1 23 4
5 5 17 3 30 6
6 6 20 6 38 10
7 8 24 12 45 15
8 9 26 16 50 17
9 14 29 19 57 24
10 20 33 24 63 30
11 22 34 25 69 33
12 23 41 26 77 40
13 26 49 28 84 45
14 31 60 32 95 51
15 34 66 40 106 56
16 38 77 48 114 61
17 40 86 51 128 68
18 46 91 55 141 74
19 52 100 60 153 81
20 59 110 68 166 86

No comments: